skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

You absolutely can't get any better ...
You absolutely can't get any better than Pagano's. Pagano's is as fresh as it comes with upbeat positive staff members. Very very helpful staff members as well. Prices are fair and worth the money. The decor is pretty cool and simple. It's hard to write a long review for this place. All I can say is 5/5 amazing place. Highly recommen ... read more
Brandon S. via yelp.com - Jul 15, 2020
Great service and super fresh fish ... read more
Brendan Manny via google.com - Jun 9, 2020
Paganos Seafood on Water Street ...
Paganos Seafood on Water Street sells the freshest fish! I didn't realize they were open and wanted to share the news.
I have been buying fish here since they opened in 1992. Highly recommend salmon and tuna.

Call 203-831-8376 for delivery or curbside.

Prices and list of seafood at ...
read more
Katherine S. via yelp.com - Apr 13, 2020
They are extremely helpful and they just don't send you home with a fish, it's on ice and comes with fresh lemon!! I mean, c'mon Who does this anymore ..that's right PAGANO'S!!
Kenneth Kinsley via google.com - Jan 9, 2019
You get what you pay for here and ...
You get what you pay for here and it is amazing! I schlepped all the way from my building in SoNo to this place (set back from the street and close to the water - definitely looked legit as I am used to the old fish markets in Chicago that all the restaurants use). Got some beautiful halibut that the fishmonger took the skin off for ... read more
Ivanka B. via yelp.com - Jan 3, 2019
Little Pricey but Always fresh!!
M DiRenzo via google.com - Dec 21, 2018
They are extremely helpful and they just don't send you home with a fish, it's on ice and comes with fresh lemon!! I mean, c'mon Who does this anymore ..that's right PAGANO'S!!
Kenneth Kinsley via google.com - Dec 1, 2018
Best sea food en around 100% fresh ... read more
Ruben Juarez via google.com - Nov 20, 2018
Good selection of fish and Seafood ... read more
Paul R via google.com - Sep 28, 2018
This place does most of their business commercially to restaurants they have a small retail area upfront. It is well worth the extra trip here. The quality is the best you can get in Connecticut. If you don’t see what you’re looking for just asked the staff and they often have more that are usually only sell commercial. Prices can ... read more
Ken Fujimori via google.com - Sep 6, 2018
I just moved to the area and this ...
I just moved to the area and this will be my choice for seafood.I tried going to Stew Leonard's and found some deals there on certain things, but as a whole, the meat was expensive and not that great looking.  This place however, has amazing looking fish.  It's not cheap, but great looking fish isn't cheap.  I'd say they are right in ... read more
Kenny R. via yelp.com - Aug 6, 2018
Great fish!
M Murray via google.com - Aug 2, 2018
William, Eva and Willie know their fish ... read more
Bellflower Foret via google.com - Jun 15, 2018
Fresh seafood with a knowledgeable, friendly staff!
North Pumiwat Shutsharawan via google.com - May 26, 2018
James...check your facts. I am clearly a woman ... read more
Jemima Pancakes via google.com - May 9, 2018
I know the founder, James Pagano, and he is gay. He said that if I give him a bj, I will get to own the market. I said I could not do it so he hates me now. Great food!
Siraj Amin via google.com - Apr 16, 2018
I am the founder of this fine establishment and I will not have its reputation tarnished by Aunt Jemima and his band of hooligans.
James Pagano via google.com - Apr 15, 2018
I know the founder, James Pagano, and he is gay ... read more
Siraj Amin via google.com - Apr 15, 2018
I banged James Pagano on the third table and the cashier register. He was a JOYful rider ... read more
Joy Katzburg via google.com - Apr 15, 2018
I wish I can give them 69 stars just like what I did to James Pagano ... read more
Thomas Williams via google.com - Apr 15, 2018
I banged James Pagano and he was a 10. I could only put 5 stars though.
Marco Jimenez via google.com - Apr 15, 2018
Best sushi fish market in the Pagano's Inc. Parking is really tiny like 20 slots at most. Otherwise you have to find street parking.
Anna Powell via google.com - Mar 19, 2018
The freshest sea food you can get ... read more
Allan Shaji Manamel via google.com - Mar 1, 2018
They have excellent seafood!
Matt Murray via google.com - Feb 6, 2018
Great seafood ... read more
Don Joako TV via google.com - Jan 9, 2018
Fresh fish for retail ... read more
Marcy Smith via google.com - Dec 23, 2017
Best seafood and service in FF county. The only place to go.
Rob Kaufman via google.com - Dec 22, 2017
Most of the time the fish is fresh ...
Most of the time the fish is fresh but unfortunately they have raised their prices and I have seen a drop in effort. Kinda sad.
Jeff G. via yelp.com - Sep 26, 2017
Freshest fish in town. Great selection. And helpful staff !
Freshest fish in town. Great selection. And helpful staff !
Bill Lopata via facebook.com - Aug 23, 2017
Freshest seafood around and great customer service. Love going to my local seafood market to get ex
Freshest seafood around and great customer service. Love going to my local seafood market to get exactly what I need!
Elise Lopata via facebook.com - Aug 23, 2017
Excellent seafood and service. Great stuff and staff.
Barbara Curtis via google.com - Aug 4, 2017
Great collection of fishes.... since I am from Nashvillle... it looks expensive, but great fishes.... little hard to find in that area...
Mohamed Rafi via google.com - Jun 7, 2017
The best fish place I've ever dealt with. The people are both nice and knowledgable. Great fish. I've used them wholesale and retail for years. I wish every business I worked with was this competent and accommodating. Nobody comes close.
Stephen Petruzzo via google.com - May 15, 2017
Excellent quality fish and excellent prices! ... read more
Nick Walker via google.com - Mar 4, 2017
Excellent quality fish and excellent prices! ... read more
Nicolas Walker via google.com - Mar 2, 2017
BRING BACK FISH AND CHIPS!
Tom Tom via google.com - Feb 21, 2017
Freshest fish. Expensive. But ...
Freshest fish. Expensive. But worth a visit for sure.
Alexandra C. via yelp.com - Dec 30, 2016
The freshest seafood in the area and reasonably priced.
Avinash Phillips via google.com - Nov 18, 2016
Let me first say,I love lobster!!!!I ...
Let me first say,I love lobster!!!!I would typically make my own because I am picky.I have ordered the lobster bake for 6 people on several different occasions and every time it's consistently perfect. I will never cook lobster at home again. Thank you Pagano's!
Kathleen B. via yelp.com - Aug 18, 2016
Excellent seafood. The best you ...
Excellent seafood. The best you likely will find in CT.   Extensive selection, and only the best.  Incredible sea scallops when available.     Although I usually cook my own shrimp (as most that you buy are over cooked and therefore like rubber,) recently I realized I was running short on time before a gathering. So I bought some of ... read more
Bob S. via yelp.com - Jun 5, 2016
We always have the best party platters for our event, Paganos is the best kept secret, our guests really enjoy the freshest seafood in Fairfield County and are always talking about how delicious the party food was weeks after. We love their little store as well, just a great customer experience!
Carol Ann McClean via google.com - Feb 17, 2016
i used to get food from here all the time at their old location, great prices and such, but -1 star because they stopped making fish and chips, and they were SO GOOD, nothing like the crap that's around here ... read more
Robert Bobbington via google.com - Nov 17, 2015
I called a few days ahead and was ...
I called a few days ahead and was quoted $30 for a gallon of fresh chopped sea clams  - went to pick them up later that week - the fishmonger in the shop wouldn't let me go without paying $50 for that same gallon... I wasn't a "commercial client". No mercy. No compromise. I've been buying these clams from this supplier, on and off, f ... read more
Chris C. via yelp.com - Sep 15, 2015
Always fresh cheap ... read more
Jane Wright via google.com - Aug 17, 2015
This is by gar the best fish market ...
This is by gar the best fish market inower fairfield county.  It may not be the most local fish but it is fresh and the selection is great. Whether you are looki g for fish, clams, oysters, shrimp, etc it is all there.   Prices reasonable and the staff is very helpful.  This is a must.
Craig C. via yelp.com - Jul 24, 2015
This is the best seafood store ...
This is the best seafood store in Fairfield County.  Very fresh seafood!  It has moved down by the harbor in South Norwalk so not particularly convenient for many of us, except of course for the local fish and shellfish for whom it is in very close proximity (presumably to their dismay).
P.J. S. via yelp.com - Feb 1, 2015
Best place to buy seafood in the ...
Best place to buy seafood in the area. Top notch product and excellent customer service.
Joey V. via yelp.com - Sep 28, 2014
The fish is always fresh and my cousin Rose works there!
The fish is always fresh and my cousin Rose works there!
Chris Furnaros via facebook.com - Apr 27, 2014
Love their seafood! Always fresh!
Love their seafood! Always fresh!
Sherri LeBel-Kruy via facebook.com - Sep 7, 2013
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire